The relaxing decor enhanced my stay, though a fireplace would have been nice.

The location was just perfect, with everything within walking distance, making it easy to explore the charming surroundings. The room was clean and had all the necessary amenities. The balcony was a fantastic addition to our stay. The staff member we interacted with was outstanding, going above and beyond to provide excellent dining suggestions during our two-night stay. I'll definitely come back if I'm in New Buffalo again!

The location was ideal, allowing easy walking access to everything. Clean and comfortable, the balcony room provided a lovely retreat. The staff member went above and beyond with dining suggestions. Homemade muffins were an unexpected delight upon return each day. Unfortunately, there seemed to be a lack of management visibility, which was a bit disappointing.

perfect location, restful decor, amazing staff advice!

We had a wonderful stay! The management was incredibly responsive, and I loved the peaceful aesthetics that made our time relaxing.

perfect spot for city strolls and quick access to parks

even though the room was smaller than expected, I really enjoyed the convenience of being just a few steps away from great dining options and local landmarks like the New Buffalo Township Memorial Park, which is perfect for a leisurely walk. The homemade muffins waiting for me at the end of each day were a delightful surprise.

Convenient online check-in and tasty homemade muffins. No manager presence noticed during stay.

I stayed for 4 nights in a King Room. The decor was classy and relaxing. Homemade muffins were a nice touch. The location was ideal for walking to attractions. Management was responsive to needs. 🏨

I thoroughly enjoyed the relaxing decor of The Neighborhood Hotel New Buffalo. The elegant furnishings and calming colors created a peaceful atmosphere, perfect for unwinding after a day of exploring. Access was simple, making it senior-friendly.

It would’ve been nice to have luggage assistance.

during my stay, i was genuinely impressed by the relaxing decor and the welcoming atmosphere. the homemade muffins were a delightful surprise, reminiscent of my previous stay at a cozy inn in new buffalo, but this place truly went above and beyond. overall, the attention to community needs and convenient access to local attractions made it an unforgettable experience.

could use luggage assistance.

Comfortable Stay with Some Hiccups

My recent four-night stay was mostly enjoyable! Toting luggage to the second floor was tough, especially with my back. I recommend opting for a first-floor room. Management addressed my bed request issue promptly. Don’t miss the on-site dining options—they really enhance the experience!

You can't beat the home's homemade muffins fresh out of the oven! Plus, the outdoor dining ambiance with picnic tables really brings those community vibes alive. Can't forget those standout amenities catering to guests' needs—like sunscreen and yoga mats! Pure gold!

Sure, the room was a bit smaller than I envisioned and, yeah, a fireplace would've been nice, but it still didn't dampen our spirits. You've got to love the cozy community area instead!

we loved our stay at neighborhood hotel! the location was just perfect for walking to nearby attractions. our king room with balcony was clean, comfy, and had all the amenities we needed. a staff member gave us great dining suggestions and was super helpful throughout our stay.

Classy and relaxing decor throughout the hotel contributes to a tranquil experience. Fresh homemade muffins in the communal kitchen were a delightful touch, pairing perfectly with the outdoor dining ambiance and picnic tables.

The King Room felt smaller than expected, making it a bit cramped. The absence of bathrobes left a missing luxury element that usually enhances comfort. Additionally, carrying luggage up to the second floor was challenging, especially considering the lack of assistance for those with mobility issues. A fireplace would have made the room cozier, adding to an intimate vibe that could elevate the stay.

Community-Focused Stay with Lovely Amenities

I had a fantastic stay enjoying the classy decor, along with the homemade muffins that were a delightful touch each day. The location made it easy to walk to nearby attractions, and the staff was incredibly helpful with dining suggestions, truly enhancing our experience. However, it would have been nice to have luggage assistance available at check-in.

Our stay was fantastic! We loved the cleanliness of our King Room with a balcony, which was perfect for morning coffee. The location was ideal for exploring nearby attractions, and the staff was incredibly helpful, giving us great dining recommendations and being attentive to our needs.

Robes would have been a nice addition.